Re: The RFC Editor's current position on Mohsen Banan's EMSD

[Mohsen BANAN <mohsen@neda.com>]

Bob,

Thank you for forwarding those notes to me.

Thank you very much for your decision to publish EMSD.



A few minor comments related to your observations are included below.

>>>>> On Sat, 9 Jan 1999 10:07:09 -0800, braden@ISI.EDU said:

  braden> 		...

  braden> 		If true and if EMSD became widely used, this could be a
  braden> 		serious issue.  Perhaps Banan could be persuaded to
  braden> 		prepare a document specifying the mapping between the
  braden> 		two mail systems.

Persuading Banan of this is going to be quite easy.

Appendix D of the spec. titled "FURTHER DEVELOPMENT" includes that
already.


  braden> 		...

  braden> 		In particular, the title of the document was presented
  braden> 		to us as: "Neda's ...".  We believe that having a
  braden> 		company name in the title in this way is completely
  braden> 		inappropriate.  We will ask Banan to remove "Neda's" from
  braden> 		the title before publication.

I have absolutely no problem with that.

Please go ahead and remove "Neda's" from the title.


  braden> ...

  braden> We will await your decision on an IESG paragraph before publishing
  braden> this document.

Please allow me to review the IESG paragraph and express my opinion on
that before publication. I will respond promptly and make sure that 
my review of the IESG paragraph does not delay the publication.


Again, thank you.

Regards,

...Mohsen.